3 Comments

Selection is different groups trying different approaches and some of them seeming to work better than others, and then other groups copying the successful. That's not what you are describing here.

Expand full comment

"Selection has less to do with how a society’s behaviors change as it gets rich."

Why couldn't selection explain this, too?

People have a genetically evolved hierarchy of needs. This causes youthful individuals to act youthful (to indulge needs beyond survival) to the extent that their survival needs are covered by family and community. It also causes wealthy societies to behave differently because the individuals composing them act more youthful to the extent that their survival needs are covered by their wealth.

Expand full comment

"Bruce Charlton wrote... 'probably adaptive in modern society'"

If "adaptive" is used here in the Darwinian sense, then it it is not obvious that "to change jobs, learn new skills, move to new places and make new friends" is adaptive. Do people who do those things reproduce more on average?

Expand full comment