4 Comments
User's avatar
Catherine Caldwell-Harris's avatar

"single party gives hostages to someone more powerful to signal their submission." People(rational actors) won't give something of value without an expeced pay-off. So it seems there are valuables expected from "signal their submission" like: "notice me and be aware of my allegiance" (so I won't be randomly attacked in the future; or offer me a place in your enclave). So this is still a two-way exchange, just, an exchange between unequal parties. Are there any contemporary examples of this? Admiration seems a bit different since the target of admiration need never know about the admiration.

Robin Hanson's avatar

I had in mind cases where the admired did know. Yes it is all going to be two way trade at some level, but in some case both parts of the trade are hostages, and in other cases only one part of the trade is a hostage.

Berder's avatar

Collard's concept of a "social miracle" doesn't seem very coherent.

> appears to be a conceptual incoherence—something close to a contradiction—in the description you would give of what it is that you want

But none of the four examples Collard gives are incoherent or contradictions. What people want in those examples can all be explained and analyzed.

TGGP's avatar

> In order to apologize, you have to avow the offending action as your own

A lot of contemporary "apologies" aren't like that, but instead are for actions someone else took in the past (such as a prior generation).