26 Comments
User's avatar
Phil Getz's avatar

> [David Sloan] Wilson says economics and economists are terrible, everything needs regulation, and we must make a world government designed to max world welfare.

Ah.

When E.O. Wilson died in 2021, Scientific American published, not an obituary, but an attack, calling Wilson just another white racist whom we should forget rather than commemorate. I remember one of its points was that Wilson had used something called the "normal distribution", which proved he was trying to establish a norm of "normality".

(The chief editor who approved that article, proving herself completely scientifically illiterate, was, last I checked, still in charge.)

I wrote to David Sloan Wilson, who often collaborated with EO Wilson, asking if he would participate in or organize some group response to this publication. He never responded. Perhaps his politics would not let him.

But this question of how to manage cultural adaptation is very like that of how to manage our own evolution, which may be the stickiest moral dilemma in the Universe. Is it better to steer evolution (in which case we will never evolve any new qualia, since you cannot value a qualia you don't have); or to stay hands-off? It appears at first to force us to choose between Maoism and Nazism.

If amphibians had learned to steer evolution, they would never have let the ability to love evolve, since it seems strictly bad to someone who hasn't experienced it.

James R. Carey's avatar

Thank you, Robin, for introducing me to Christopher Boehm (1931-2021). His book, Hierarchy in the Forest: The Evolution of Egalitarian Behavior (2001), includes the following quotes. From page 5: “Humans were egalitarian for thousands of generations before hierarchical societies began to appear.” From page 32: “The nuclear families in human societies are scarcely void of hierarchy. Why then do the main political actors at the band level behave as equals?” From page 35: “A distinctively egalitarian political style is highly predictable whenever people live in small, locally autonomous social and economic groups, and in my opinion this situation is likely to have a single causal explanation.”

I spent my career studying and attempting to replicate the Toyota model in the organizations where I worked. It is now obvious to me that Toyota was replicating the social structure of the hunter-gather band in a modern context.

We do not have to be deliberate for culture to evolve maladaptively. We do have to be deliberate for culture to evolve adaptively. Dilemmas (conflicts of interest within the system) inevitably emerge. If dilemmas are being resolved one-by-one in the sequence in which they emerge, then cultural evolution is adaptive.

A hunter-gather band is a team of teams. Dilemmas are resolved within a team of hunters, or gatherers, or a nuclear family, or the band council.

The Toyota I studied replicated that structure in a large multi-national business organization by focusing on the development of the individual team in a way that is deliberately balanced between two dimensions, performance (getting the job done) and team spirit (all for one and one for all).

Question: Who is in control?

Answer: Our uniquely human and genetically inherited nature.

Swami's avatar

Interesting points!

“We do not have to be deliberate for culture to evolve maladaptively. We do have to be deliberate for culture to evolve adaptively.”

Could you explain or expand on the emphasis on deliberateness? Seems to me that much of our adaptive culture was emergent, and thus not deliberate.

“Dilemmas (conflicts of interest within the system) inevitably emerge. If dilemmas are being resolved one-by-one in the sequence in which they emerge, then cultural evolution is adaptive.”

It seems that most species, including many extremely adaptive ones do fine without ever resolving conflict of interests between individuals. Does cultural evolution require higher levels of coordination than biological evolution?

James R. Carey's avatar

Thank you for your good questions.

Dilemmas do not resolve themselves. They require two limited interests to work together with the deliberate goal of deriving a resolution that serves their common interest.

Tampering (repeatedly changing a misunderstood system without learning from the experience) certainly makes things worse.

An individual animal is either a life system or a subject of a social (life) system. Life systems do fine without ever resolving "between life system" conflicts of interests. If fellow subjects of a social system are resolving dilemmas one-by-one as they emerge, then the system is healthy.

We effectively left biological evolution in the rearview mirror at the origin of our species. Cultural evolution certainly requires much higher levels of coordination, but it delivers much higher levels of reward (and much higher levels of risk).

Swami's avatar

“Dilemmas do not resolve themselves. They require two limited interests to work together with the deliberate goal of deriving a resolution that serves their common interest.”

I hear what you are saying and might even say that these are useful heuristics. But sometimes changing circumstances resolve dilemmas, sometimes one party sees a local breakthrough that the other is not aware of, sometimes dilemmas involve lots more than two people, sometimes they resolve themselves via accident (aka variation and selection), and sometimes a top down controller commands a solution which the parties benefit from without necessarily agreeing with.

“Tampering (repeatedly changing a misunderstood system without learning from the experience) certainly makes things worse.”

You seem to be arguing for deliberate evolution rather than the kind where we try a hundred things and keep what works, iterating on that. I see a role for both, but most of the tue winners come from trial and error and constructive competition not deliberate design. IMO

“Cultural evolution certainly requires much higher levels of coordination, but it delivers much higher levels of reward (and much higher levels of risk).”

I agree.

James R. Carey's avatar

A few definitions will help. A “party” is an individual person or an identifiable group of people of any size. A “dilemma” is a conflict that has emerged in an interaction between two parties. Conflicts involving more than two parties involve more than one dilemma.

You are correct that cultural evolution can be the result of a random accident. However, biological evolution is always the result of a random accident, and cultural evolution is not limited by that constraint.

Question: How did our prehistoric ancestors start as a tiny population struggling to survive at the origin of our species (roughly 12,000 generations ago) and end as Earth’s dominant vertebrate species at the dawn of the Neolithic Period (roughly 400 generations ago)?

Answer: They used our superpower, which is deliberate cultural evolution.

Phil Getz's avatar

Wilson: "Avoid the temptation of centralized planning. You and your expert consultants are not smart enough to know how to improve the complex system that is under your care. You should implement the core design principles, which are fundamentally inclusive. You should also implement evolutionary processes that identify the right targets of selection, monitor planned and unplanned variation, and replicate best practices, knowing that their implementation will be highly sensitive to context."

It's very interesting that Wilson separates authoritarian goal-selection from authoritarian planning. I was about to say that he may be the first person to do this, but there is a previous example: Hitler, who set goals, but refused to tell his underlings how to achieve them. He wanted them to fight it out between themselves, to make the organization stronger.

That comes across as a cheap shot at Wilson; but, as I said in another comment, there are no obvious non-evil approaches here. I'm sure he's nicer than Hitler. I just don't think niceness will help here.

In fact, I'll throw out this hypothesis: Morality is bad in omnipotent beings. A being of sufficient power will do greater harm if it's moral than if it's amoral. Hitler was an extreme moralizer. (A week ago I wouldn't have said that, but I've been shocked this past week to see the old Nazi Kultur vs Zivilisation arguments re-emerge from people opposing AI successionism. Anti-successionism is extremely moralistic, and very Nazi.) Morality is a bias, and the emergence of complexity from the simple can't happen with any bias away from the narrow edge-of-chaos band in which life emerges.

TGGP's avatar

Futarchy has voting determine goals, while betting determines how best to achieve them.

Phil Getz's avatar

I don't see the connection between futarchy and goal-setting. Futarchy extracts honest priors from the population. This helps us distribute resources more efficiently, say between different threats. Does it tell us anything about what people value?

TGGP's avatar

Hanson's slogan for futarchy is "vote on values, bet on beliefs".

Phil Getz's avatar

Oh, right. After all this focus on prediction markets, I forgot about voting on the utility function.

Phil Getz's avatar

BTW, these 2 parts are separable. You can imagine our existing system passing laws which specify the form of a utility function to be implemented, and having citizens vote on the values to provide the utility function (such as by giving each citizen the same number of points to distribute). You can also imagine more bespoke laws, say the yearly congressional budget, which are dynamics laws containing variables whose values are updated periodically or continuously based on prediction markets. For instance, prediction markets about military conflicts could dynamically adjust military budgets.

So they could be implemented one first, then the other, then combined more efficiently.

Dave92f1's avatar

A scary downhill progression into what Hayek called "constructivism". Esp. Wilson sounds like a meta-Mao. (I hear Bullwinkle Moose confidently saying "This time for sure! Last time we didn't have the right targets of selection, didn't monitor planned and unplanned variation, didn't replicate best practices. But THIS time...").

I think Skinner was quoting C. S. Lewis' _The Abolition of Man_ (1943), which does seem relevant (recommended; it's short).

Lewis makes the larger point that, should we intentionally design people or society, that which we design will do the same - design their own descendent cultures/people. But they'll do so differently than we would, because they're different. Etc., recursively down the generations. Without some kind of anchor to survival/functionality, the path seems unpredictable, potentially chaotic, and likely to lead to extinction. Yes, capitalism could fix this, but it seems unlikely to be allowed to.

I don't think there's a solution to your concern about cultural drift short of expanding into the solar system, and eventually beyond, to get diversity of culture and competition working again. I see it as a candidate Great Filter - a monocultural self-propagating virus not subject to competitive pressures that extinguishes itself before it spreads widely enough to not be a monoculture.

[Apologies if I'm repeating myself here; I do tend to harp on this.]

Robin Hanson's avatar

Even if spread across stars, I think each star system will need a stronger local mechanism to evolve culture.

Dave92f1's avatar

I think a lot depends on the costs, and time requirements, for interplanetary/interstellar travel.

John Ketchum's avatar

Perhaps part of the solution is to decentralize deliberate cultural evolution rather than asking a common governance mechanism to optimize culture for everyone. Voluntary communities could adopt different institutional and cultural arrangements, allowing experimentation, comparison, imitation, and revision. That would preserve deliberate variation and selection while avoiding the need for a single authority to specify the objective function. The difficult condition is meaningful exit: people must be able to move among alternatives, without treating every ordinary cost of leaving as coercion. This would make cultural evolution partly a process of selection among institutional arrangements rather than selection imposed upon individuals by their governors.

Robin Hanson's avatar

The harder problem is that few seem interested in deep cultural variety, especially insular versions. Most love to mix, talk, and trade with the world, and only like a shallow multiculturalism.

John Ketchum's avatar

That's a good point, but perhaps deep cultural variety should emerge from voluntary choice. The framework need not require insular communities; it only needs to permit them. People could then reveal through association and exit how much cultural separation or integration they actually want.

Robin Hanson's avatar

People are in fact so free, thus the world you now see shows you how many people want how much varied insularity: not very much.

John Ketchum's avatar

I'm not sure existing arrangements give us a clean revealed-preference test. People are not generally free to enter any political jurisdiction they choose; some face restrictions on leaving, and the range of available institutional alternatives is largely fixed by territory. People also generally cannot choose among substantially different governance systems while remaining where they live. Moreover, some people want alternative arrangements for themselves, while others want to impose their preferred arrangement on everyone. What we observe, therefore, reflects a mixture of preference and political constraint; it doesn't tell us how much cultural or institutional variety people would choose if the feasible set were broader.