Overcoming Bias

Share this post

Five Important Topics

www.overcomingbias.com

Discover more from Overcoming Bias

This is a blog on why we believe and do what we do, why we pretend otherwise, how we might do better, and what our descendants might do, if they don't all die.
Over 11,000 subscribers
Continue reading
Sign in

Five Important Topics

Robin Hanson
Nov 23, 2020
Share this post

Five Important Topics

www.overcomingbias.com
11
Share

Some topics are especially important. You might think that on such topics we’d try extra hard to be more accurate, both individually and institutionally. Alas, we are also more likely to self-deceive on them, both individually and institutionally.

So on such topics you should less trust both your intuition and the usual institutions. Be more skeptical of all sources, and more eager to find especially reliable sources. At least if you were trying to be accurate. Which you probably aren’t.

What are these most important topics? Simple biology predicts (at least) the following five, ordered from the top down by the fraction of species for which they are important:

Death – All individuals of all species die, which is a terribly important event. As La Rochefoucauld said “Neither the sun nor death can be looked at with a steady eye.” For poor humans food, water, shelter, and many other topics are about death.

Sex/Fertility – All species reproduce, and most do this via sex. For sexual species, sex is as important as death, and easier to deceive associates about.

Status – Many animal species maintain status hierarchies, and in such species it is important both to rise in status, and to judge status well. We self-deceive on our own suitability for status, and on how high status folks differ.

Politics – Primate social groups often split into conflicting coalitions. In that case it is important to be an attractive coalition partner, and to judge partners well. We self-deceive on how our coalitions differ, and on other topics to show loyalty to our faction.

Honesty – Only a species that can communicate can care about honesty (I.e., accuracy), but humans communicate by far the most. And if we are dishonest on important topics, then we must also be dishonest on the topic of our honesty. Yet our reputations for honesty are important to us.

Note that these are also topics on which many seem quite emotionally sensitive, and where norms, laws, and retribution often limit who can say what. And even when people claim to not care about such things, those meta opinions seems to be very important to them.

Note also that many other important topics can be seem as combinations of the above. For example, class is inherited (i.e., fertility driven) status, medicine is death managed by status, and males are the sex designed to die more easily.

I’m painfully aware of how sensitive is the topic of sex/fertility, as I’ve been partially cancelled on the basis of a few brief remarks on that. But if this is a topic on which accuracy is harder, shouldn’t I be more reluctant to have opinions on it?

Yes, but the main thing I said that bothered people was to suggest that sex/fertility might be important to big groups of people. (To husbands who raise kids not theirs, and to people who get zero sex.) And one thing it seems we can be especially confident about these topics is that they are probably important to many people. We are evolved talking social creatures, and these topics are important to the survival and selection of such creatures. Thus I defended a claim about which we can all be especially sure, and doing that apparently induces an unusually strong retribution.

Share this post

Five Important Topics

www.overcomingbias.com
11
Share
11 Comments
Share this discussion

Five Important Topics

www.overcomingbias.com
Brian Holtz
May 15

Is Slate the creepiest pseudo-highbrow news site? I opened their article about Robin in an incognito window (so nobody can blame cookies), and the click bait I was shown included:

* My Boyfriend’s Job Makes It Impossible for Him to Do My Favorite Sex Act * My Shy, Sexually Naïve Husband Has Become Great in Bed—but I Just Can’t Do What He Wants Now * I Thought I Had Lost My Desire for Sex—Until I Cheated on My Husband * I Figured Out an Incredible Sexual Trick—Then It Ruined My Life* I Don’t Know How to Tell Men About My Sexual “Surprise”* The 50 Most Beautiful Women Of All Time* Melissa Rauch Down Sized Her Bikini (Photos)* Cosplay Costumes That Went A Little Too Far. #37 Will Shock You

Slate's editorial preaching about what is the most important form of inequality just got curb-stomped by Slate's business practice about what is their readers' biggest motivator.

Expand full comment
Reply
Share
free_agent
May 15

All of this is modulated by Trivers' observation that deceit is a fundamental part of animal communication, and thus there will be a separation between the information we use to make decisions (subconscious) and the information we present to others (conscious). We would expect the two to converge only when one's particular interests are not directly affected by the information presented, and rewards are gained only by presenting the most accurate model of the world. For example, within the culture and rituals of academic discourse, by professors who have a guaranteed income for life.

Expand full comment
Reply
Share
9 more comments...
Top
New
Community

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 Robin Hanson
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing