3 Comments

Yes to this. Though I think there's also another category of thing that we often don't see clearly. That's institutions which work in different ways for a lot of different people. My favourite example is education, which suits the purposes of those who think children should be morally trained, those who think children should be vocationally trained, and those who just want some childcare. There is massive contradiction in the desires and aims of all the people who participate in the education institution, and if we ever talked about them, the whole thing would fall apart. But it works so well for all the different groups that we learn to avoid ever letting our conversations about it reach the sticking point. I think similar situations obtain with prisons, and marriage, and the church (for a long time).So yes, some things we avoid applying our real knowledge because we choose to join a shared conception of sacredness; and some things we avoid applying our real opinions to because we choose to join an institution of convenience.

Expand full comment

Why can't I tell the true shape of Lushan? Because I myself am in the mountain.

Expand full comment

Does this difficulty in knowing what we want have any influence on the development of strategies for changing what we want?

I want to want to eat healthy food I want to want to exerciseI want to want to quit bad habits

Etc

It seems like there are many cases where actions are more desirable in the abstract than up close.

Expand full comment