Discussion about this post

User's avatar
srdiamond's avatar

I did a search on OB for Dreamtime, and it netted an interesting group of posts. But I don't see what leads Robin to conclude that our late-industrial civilization is far-mode oriented. Robin seems to base the idea that we're deluded in a distinctively far sort of way from what he takes to be our excessive optimism about the distant future. Even if this is due to far mode (to me it seems based on near-mode extrapolation), it doesn't prove that we are generally dominated by an outsized far mode, inasmuch as nobody really much cares about the distant future. [Added.] Robin emphasizes our propensity for vicarious experience, but this is an increasingly near-mode form of experience,[reality TV is the ultimate] perhaps contrasted with more far-mode reading a century or two ago.

On the merits of the various forecasts: hypothetically granting Robin's technological projections, whether we'll be reduced to Malthusian misery seems to depend entirely on the prospects for economic centralism, i.e., world socialism.

Expand full comment
Overcoming Bias Commenter's avatar

He desires a libertarian world and considers opposition to things like slavery and efforts in favor of making the world a better place for everyone (not just the happy few) to be naive, because truly an advanced civilization with all the wonders of nanotech and genetic enhancements at its fingertips should choose to make 95% of its population live lives far more miserable than that of the unluckiest cave man.

Expand full comment
14 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?