Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Alexander Gabriel's avatar

I have reversed on the "unlikely vs. says nothing useful" bit.

http://humanpetition.blogsp...

Vinge seems right that we can't predict what exactly a singularity would be like, but I agree with Will Sawin that it would pose a danger to humankind.

Expand full comment
Alexander Gabriel's avatar

I would agree it does leave a big gap.

More broadly though, the question is whether considering changes this large ever leads to anything productive.

http://humanpetition.blogsp...

I think the best criticism of the singularity idea is not that it's unlikely but that nothing useful can be said about it.

Expand full comment
16 more comments...

No posts