Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Robin Hanson's avatar

There certainly were businesses with more than one person, and places where more than one person lived nearby.

Expand full comment
Overcoming Bias Commenter's avatar

"Before the industrial revolution, there were very few firms of any substantial scale. So during the farming era firms existed but could not have been distributed by Zipf’s law. So if firms had a power law distribution then, it must have had a much steeper power.

If we look all the way back to the forager era, then cities and nations could also not plausibly have had a Zipf distribution — there just were none of any substantial scale. So surely their size distribution also fell off faster than Zipf, as individual income does today."

There were far fewer firms, and far fewer cities. If they had a Zipf distribution, there would necessarily be none of any substantial scale by modern standards. You're drawing a conclusion with no discriminatory hypothesis and no data.

Expand full comment
1 more comment...

No posts