Discover more from Overcoming Bias
Among adults of industrial nations, growth stunting … is associated with worse indicators of adult well-being (e.g., income). … Here we … [consider] the Tsimane’, a foraging-farming society of native Amazonians in Bolivia. Subjects included 248 women and 255 men measured annually during five consecutive years (2002-2006). Nine outcomes (wealth, monetary income, illness, access to credit, mirth, schooling, math skills, plant knowledge, forest clearance) were regressed separately against a stunting dummy variable and a wide range of control variables. We found no significant association between any of the indicators of own well-being and adult stunting. …
In South Africa, a comparison of short-for-age “Cape Coloured” children showed that those growing up under poorer socioeconomic conditions had lower body weight, height, and physical performance than the more advantaged children … Among adults of industrial nations, standing physical stature is positively associated with many indicators of own adult well-being, such as occupation, monetary income, wages, IQ, longevity, and good health.
More here.
Height Puzzle
> Most farming/foraging societies put their kids to work at a fairly young age, when they are still small, and kids might even be a win, in terms of the ratio of calories produced to those consumed. Their caloric requirements at that age are also small, even when they are working hard.
I dunno; how would that work, exactly? I would expect kid labor to be less efficient than adult labor simply because kids need extra calories for growing, while adults aren't growing.
The Status Syndrome: maybe low status is debilitating in itself.