6 Comments

"Once you can guess which directions are 'up', you can work to push outcomes in such directions. Even if you can’t push very far, you may still do the best you can, and perhaps make an important difference." But it's not unlikely that the "up" direction in possible-world space depends on my efficacy. Pushing in a certain direction might give me the best result if I can move only one unit away from what I would get by "doing nothing," but pushing in quite a different direction might be better if I can move five units away, etc. So I'd need a good estimate of my strength in order to know which way to push.

Note: I take it that the issue is what *I* can do. *We*--whatever, exactly, is the collection to which this refers--have more power than *I* have; but *I* am the relevant agent.

Expand full comment

To be clear, I didn't mean literal heaven, hell, I meant heaven and hell on earth. Either everyone uploads to the Noosphere (utility: positive infinity), or everything is just a boot stamping on a human face forever (utility: negative infinity).

Yes, I could die or commit suicide to avoid these fates, but when I think of the distant future I don't really have all that much more concern for my future self than I do for human beings in general.

Given this view of the world, I don't think it makes sense to try to make marginal adjustments to the outcomes--the important thing is the probabilities of the outcomes.

Expand full comment

Or you could die and cease to persist as an experiencing entity.

Expand full comment

My subjective probabilities of the future are as follows:

50% change of Hell.50% chance of Heaven.

Small changes within either of these scenarios do not matter to me at all. The best I can hope for, if there is any hope at all, is to make a marginally positive change in the probability.

Expand full comment

The Amish have little to no influence outside their local environment, and are extremely vulnerable to existential threats. I think control over your future corresponds to how capable you are of adapting to the future you find yourself in.

Expand full comment

Are the Amish in control of their future? Perhaps we're just not willing to make any hard choices about which technologies we use.

Expand full comment