Overcoming Bias

Share this post

Bias Against Introverts?

www.overcomingbias.com

Bias Against Introverts?

Robin Hanson
Mar 9, 2007
Share this post

Bias Against Introverts?

www.overcomingbias.com

Echoing an earlier Atlantic article, Mary Carpenter suggests we are biased against introverts:

As Barbara Ehrenreich wrote in a Time magazine column about personality tests, "Their chief function as far as I could tell . . . was to weed out the introverts. When asked whether you’d rather be the life of the party or curl up with a book, the correct answer is always, ‘Party!’ " … self-help books that include blatantly stupid questions … paints introverts as "over-critical," "pessimistic" and "anxious," and describes them as feeling "unaccepted, unacceptable or simply inferior."  It’s enough to make an introvert mad. … My enormous, extended and extroverted family still poses a challenge, especially on the small island where we converge for a few weeks every summer. … But the family is making strides in recognizing its introverted minority.

With a little search I find that the shy and introverted both suffer in many ways: 

Introversion is indeed more active than shyness in inhibiting religious disposition.  … Very Conservative males reported the lowest rate of overall shyness. … Non-shy respondents reported the highest rate of starting their own business, … Non-shyness and extroversion reported the highest household income levels …Shyness has a greater impact on the reduction on eye contact than does introversion. … Those with the lowest rates of eye contact achieve the lowest ranks [at the workplace].

We might posit a grand conspiracy of extroverts to keep introverts down, but a more plausible explanation to me is that extroversion is just valued more by society and business.   

I was a shy young nerd and thought I was an introvert, but eventually learned that I was reacting to the fact that other people didn’t like to be around me.  Once I found people who liked to be around me, I loved to be around them too, and was often the last person to leave from a party.   Of course it is possible that my personality changed.

Share this post

Bias Against Introverts?

www.overcomingbias.com
Comments
TopNewCommunity

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 Robin Hanson
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing